Shopify discount strategies: how to use discounts without damaging your brand
Disclaimer: This article contains affiliate links. If you decide to start a Shopify store using my link, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products or services I love, and as Shopify designer, it’s no surprise that I’m a big fan of Shopify!
Discounts aren’t inherently bad - in fact they can be great for your business growth when done properly! They can increase cash flow, move stock and grow your email list quickly…
But they can also reduce the perceived value of your products, shrink your margins and train customers to wait for the next sale.
The difference isn’t whether you use discounts. It’s how and when you use them.
If you run a Shopify store and you’re wondering whether discounts are helping or hurting your growth, here’s how to think about them strategically and see if it’s right for your business.
The pros and cons of running discounts on Shopify
Before jumping into tactics, it’s worth being honest about both sides.
The benefits of offering discounts
Discounts can:
Create urgency during slow sales periods
Move older or seasonal stock
Increase first-time purchases
Grow your email list quickly when customers sign up to your newsletter in exchange for the discount.
Boost short-term revenue
If you’re heading into a quieter season or launching a new product line, a well-timed promotion can create momentum.
The downsides of discounting too often
The risk comes when discounts become routine. If customers expect 10–20% off every few weeks, full-price sales become harder. Over time, this can:
Reduce the perceived value of your products
Lower your profit margins
Attract price-sensitive customers who don’t become loyal
Undermine your premium positioning as a brand
For boutique or design-led brands especially, constant discounting can quietly chip away at brand credibility. The key is using discounts deliberately and strategically, not reactively or because you’ve been told that you should offer discounts.
Using discounts to grow your email list
One of the smartest ways to use discounts is in exchange for something valuable: an email address.
Offering a first-order discount in return for signing up can:
Build your email list quickly
Allow you to nurture customers long-term
Increase lifetime value beyond the initial sale
Email marketing is far more stable than relying purely on social media and unpredictable algorithms. Once someone is on your list, you can introduce new products, restocks and limited releases directly to their inbox.
On Shopify, this can be done through pop-ups or newsletter forms and welcome flows - although, at the time of writing this blog post, you’ll need a premium theme for the pop-up feature. The important part is keeping it aligned with your brand. A subtle, well-designed offer performs better than an aggressive flashing banner.
Think of the discount as an entry point into a longer relationship where you continue to nurture the client through your regular emails, not just a one-off sale.
Discounts as a short-term boost during slow seasons
Every ecommerce brand experiences quieter periods - and that’s ok!
Rather than panicking, you can use a time-limited promotion strategically. For example:
A short seasonal sale
A promotion on a specific product or range that you want to shift
A birthday or brand anniversary offer
A limited “VIP weekend” for subscribers
The key is making it feel occasional and purposeful rather than constant, as if every month becomes a “special sale,” customers stop seeing it as special and are training to expect a discount rather than paying full price.
Offer discounts on specific products, not your entire store
Blanket discounts across your entire store can be costly.
Instead, consider:
Discounting end-of-line products
Promoting slower-moving stock
Offering a discount on a second item
Running category-specific promotions
This allows you to protect your margins on your bestsellers while still driving sales elsewhere.
Alternatives to traditional discounts
If you want to increase the average order value without reducing the price, there are other options:
1. Free gifts with purchase
Instead of 15% off, you might offer:
A free mini product
A sample size
A small accessory
This maintains your product’s perceived value while still rewarding customers.
2. Product bundles
Using a Shopify bundles app, you can create curated sets at a slightly reduced combined price.
Bundles work well because they:
Increase basket size
Feel intentional rather than discounted
Help customers discover complementary products
For example, a skincare routine bundle or a “complete the look” fashion set often converts better than a generic sitewide discount.
3. Free shipping thresholds
Offering free shipping over a certain amount encourages customers to add one more item to their cart. A top tip is to make the free shipping value just slightly above the average order value, so that more customers are encouraged to add an extra item to get free shipping. This increases average order value without reducing your product prices directly.
So, should you discount?
Discounts aren’t inherently good or bad.
They’re tools that you can use to your advantage.
Used occasionally and strategically, discounts can boost your revenue and grow your customer base. Used too often and reactively, they can weaken your brand positioning and margins.
For many of the Shopify brands I work with, the real growth comes from improving structure, upselling properly and refining the customer journey. Discounts then become an additional sales strategy rather than something you need to rely on.
If you’re relying on discounts to drive every sale
That’s usually a sign your store structure and discount strategy needs attention.
When your product pages, upsells and navigation are working properly, you shouldn’t need to rely on price reductions to convert customers.
I design strategic Shopify websites for product brands who want to increase sales sustainably, without constantly leaning on discounts. If you’re ready to build a store that supports growth properly, you can explore my Shopify website design services or get in touch to arrange a call.
FAQs
-
No, they can be useful for promotions, stock clearance or list growth. The issue arises when they’re used too frequently and reduce perceived value.
The key is to use discounts strategically rather than constantly.
-
There’s no fixed rule, but keeping them occasional, limiting the number of users per customer, and keeping them purposeful tends to protect brand positioning and margins.
-
If you don’t want to reduce your prices, there are plenty of ways to increase sales without discounting.
You could offer a free gift with purchase, which maintains your product’s value while still rewarding customers. Bundles are another strong option. By grouping complementary products together at a slightly better combined price, you increase average order value without training customers to expect sitewide sales.
Free shipping thresholds also work well. Instead of discounting, you encourage customers to add one more item to unlock free delivery, which often increases basket size naturally.
You can also focus on improving your upsell sections, adding “pairs well with” recommendations, refining your product pages and introducing loyalty rewards for repeat customers. In many cases, structural improvements to your Shopify store will have a bigger long-term impact than a short-term discount ever could.
-
A first-time purchase discount can work well, especially if it’s used to grow your email list and encourage hesitant customers to place their first order. For newer visitors, a small incentive can be enough to tip them into buying.
If you choose to offer one, keep it modest, tie it to email sign-up and make sure you have a strong follow-up email flow in place. For more premium brands, you might test alternatives like a small gift or early access instead of a straight percentage off.
